commercial low legal theory –

1. Deterrence theory of criminal punishment is criticized for, among others, treating individuals as a means to societal ends. Do you think that is a legitimate criticism? Why or why not? Discuss thoroughly. 10%

2. According to Ronald Dworkin, legal rules apply in an “all-or-nothing fashion.” Legal principles, by contrast, do not apply in an all or nothing fashion. What does he mean? Explain exhaustively, using your own examples. 10